Topic 2

Telling aldehydes from ketones

Aldehydes are oxidised to carboxylic acids even by mild oxidising agents. Ketones are not. Two classic tests use this difference. A third test looks for a particular group, CH₃CO–, instead.

Predict first

Pentan-2-one (CH₃COCH₂CH₂CH₃) and pentan-3-one (CH₃CH₂COCH₂CH₃) have the same formula, C₅H₁₀O. Which test tells them apart?

Tollens' test: warm the compound with Tollens' reagent (ammoniacal silver nitrate). An aldehyde reduces Ag⁺ to silver, which coats the glass as a bright silver mirror. Fehling's test: warm it with Fehling's solution. An aldehyde gives a reddish-brown precipitate of Cu₂O. Aromatic aldehydes such as benzaldehyde do not give Fehling's test.

Iodoform test: I₂ with NaOH (sodium hypoiodite) reacts with compounds that have a CH₃CO– group and gives a yellow precipitate of iodoform, CHI₃. Methyl ketones and ethanal have this group. Alcohols with a CH₃CH(OH)– group also give the test, because the reagent first oxidises them to CH₃CO–.

Pick a compound and read its three tests

CH₃CHO

aldehyde (–CHO)?
yes, aliphatic
has CH₃CO–?
yes
Results for ethanal
TestResult
Tollens' reagent, warmpositive: silver mirror
Fehling's solution, warmpositive: reddish-brown Cu₂O
I₂ + NaOH (iodoform)positive: yellow CHI₃

Watch ethanal and methanal

Ethanal is the only aldehyde that gives the iodoform test, because CH₃–CHO contains CH₃CO–. Methanal has no CH₃ group and does not.