Topic 1
Why aldehydes react faster than ketones
Before you start
A **carbonyl group** is C=O. An **aldehyde** has at least one H on the carbonyl carbon (–CHO). A **ketone** has two carbon groups on it (R–CO–R′). R stands for an alkyl or aryl group.
Oxygen pulls the electrons of the C=O bond toward itself, so the carbonyl carbon is δ+ and the oxygen δ−. A nucleophile (Nu⁻) attacks the carbon, and the C=O becomes a single C–O bond. This is nucleophilic addition, the typical reaction of aldehydes and ketones. Adding HCN to give a cyanohydrin is the standard example.
Predict first
Which of these adds HCN fastest?
Pick a compound: how open is the carbonyl carbon?
- groups that are not H
- 0
- speed of addition
- fastest of the four
HCHO. Two H atoms: no crowding and no electron push, so the carbon is the most positive.
Two effects work together. Steric: bigger groups crowd the carbonyl carbon and get in the nucleophile's way. Electronic: alkyl groups push electrons toward the carbon and reduce its δ+ charge. A ketone has two such groups, an aldehyde one or none.
HCHO > CH₃CHO > CH₃COCH₃
order of reactivity in nucleophilic addition
Benzaldehyde is less reactive than aliphatic aldehydes such as propanal. Resonance with the ring makes its carbonyl carbon less positive.