Topic 4

What makes a carboxylic acid stronger

Carboxylic acids are much stronger acids than alcohols and phenols. When –COOH loses H⁺, the negative charge of the carboxylate ion, –COO⁻, is shared equally by two oxygen atoms through resonance. In the phenoxide ion part of the charge sits on ring carbons, which hold it less well than oxygen.

Acid strength is given as pKa: the lower the pKa, the stronger the acid, and each unit lower means ten times stronger. Ethanoic acid (acetic acid) has pKa 4.76, and phenol 10.0.

Predict first

Which acid is the strongest?

Pick an acid and compare it with ethanoic acid

pKa (a shorter bar is a stronger acid)phenol10.0propanoic4.88ethanoic4.76benzoic4.19methanoic3.75bromoethanoic2.90chloroethanoic2.86fluoroethanoic2.660246810
pKa
4.76
compared with ethanoic acid
this is the reference

Groups that withdraw electrons, such as halogens, –NO₂ and –CN, stabilise the carboxylate ion and make the acid stronger. Groups that donate electrons, such as alkyl groups, do the opposite. That is why methanoic acid (3.75) is stronger than ethanoic acid (4.76), which is stronger than propanoic acid (4.88).

A phenyl ring attached directly to –COOH also makes the acid stronger: benzoic acid has pKa 4.19.

Two more rules

More halogen atoms make a stronger acid, so Cl₃CCOOH is stronger than ClCH₂COOH. And the effect fades with distance: a halogen on the carbon next to –COOH counts for much more than one further along the chain.