Topic 3

Resonance in benzene

Some molecules cannot be shown by one structure. Benzene, C₆H₆, can be drawn as a ring of six carbons with alternating single and double bonds, and there are two ways to place the double bonds. These are its two Kekulé structures.

A normal C–C single bond is 154 pm long and a C=C double bond is 134 pm (1 pm = 10⁻¹² m).

Predict first

When the C–C bond lengths in benzene are measured, what is found?

Benzene, drawn two waysStep 1 / 3
expected: 3 × 134 pm, 3 × 154 pm

Kekulé structure I. Double bonds on three sides of the ring. If this were the real molecule, three bonds would be 134 pm and three 154 pm.

Text version
  1. Kekulé structure I. Double bonds on three sides of the ring. If this were the real molecule, three bonds would be 134 pm and three 154 pm.
  2. Kekulé structure II. The double bonds have moved to the other three sides. The carbon atoms have not moved; only electrons have.
  3. The real molecule is the hybrid of I and II. The π electrons are spread evenly round the ring, drawn as a circle, and every C–C bond is 139 pm.

The structures that can be drawn are resonance structures or canonical forms. Only electrons move between them; the nuclei stay in the same places. The real molecule is the resonance hybrid, and it is more stable than any single structure. The extra stability is the resonance energy.

Groups joined to a π system can push or pull electrons through resonance. +R groups give electrons to the ring: halogens, –OH, –OR, –NH₂. −R groups pull electrons from it: –COOH, –CHO, >C=O, –CN, –NO₂.

One group, two effects

Chlorine pulls electrons by induction (−I) but gives a lone pair by resonance (+R). –OH and –NH₂ are the same, while –NO₂ pulls both ways (−I and −R). Keep the two effects separate when you compare groups.