Topic 2

The inductive effect

When carbon bonds to a more electronegative atom such as chlorine, the shared pair is pulled towards chlorine. Chlorine gets a small negative charge, δ−, and the carbon a small positive charge, δ+. That carbon then pulls a little on its own neighbour, and so on down the chain.

Predict first

Which of these acids is the strongest?

The pull of chlorine, bond by bondStep 1 / 4
CC-4CC-3CC-2CC-1Clsize of δ+ (not to scale)

1-Chlorobutane, CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂Cl. Chlorine is more electronegative than carbon.

Text version
  1. 1-Chlorobutane, CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂Cl. Chlorine is more electronegative than carbon.
  2. Chlorine pulls the C–Cl bond pair towards itself. Chlorine becomes δ− and C-1 becomes δ+.
  3. C-1, now slightly positive, pulls a little on the C-2–C-1 bond pair. C-2 gets a smaller charge, δδ+.
  4. C-3 gets an even smaller charge, δδδ+. By C-4 the effect is too small to matter: it fades within about three bonds.

This shift of σ electrons along a chain is the inductive effect. It is permanent and dies away quickly, becoming negligible after about three bonds. Groups that pull electrons show a −I effect: halogens, –NO₂, –CN, –COOH. Alkyl groups such as –CH₃ push electrons and show a +I effect.

More halogen atoms near the –COOH group give a stronger acid, so Cl₃CCOOH > Cl₂CHCOOH > ClCH₂COOH > CH₃COOH. A more electronegative halogen pulls harder, so FCH₂COOH is stronger than ClCH₂COOH.

Electromeric effect

In a multiple bond, an attacking reagent can make the π electron pair move completely to one atom. This is the electromeric effect. Unlike the inductive effect it is temporary: it lasts only while the reagent is present.