Topic 3

Positive and negative deviations

A solution that obeys Raoult's law at every composition is ideal. Mixing it gives out no heat and changes no volume: ΔmixH = 0 and ΔmixV = 0. This happens when the attraction between A and B molecules is about the same as A to A and B to B. n-Hexane with n-heptane, and bromoethane with chloroethane, come close.

If A to B attractions are weaker, molecules escape more easily and the vapour pressure is higher than Raoult's law predicts: a positive deviation. If A to B attractions are stronger, molecules are held back and the vapour pressure is lower: a negative deviation.

Predict first

When chloroform and acetone are mixed, a hydrogen bond forms between the two kinds of molecule. How does the vapour pressure of the mixture compare with Raoult's law?

Pick a kind of solution

020040060000.51mole fraction of Btotal vapour pressure (mm Hg)azeotrope

Dashed: Raoult's law. Blue: the real mixture (schematic).

ΔmixH
> 0 (absorbs heat)
ΔmixV
> 0 (expands)
attractions
A–B weaker
example
ethanol + acetone
azeotrope
minimum boiling

A large deviation gives a maximum or minimum in the vapour pressure curve. A mixture at that composition boils without changing composition and cannot be separated by fractional distillation. It is an azeotrope.

The two azeotropes to remember

Positive deviation gives a **minimum boiling** azeotrope: ethanol and water, at about 95% ethanol by volume. Negative deviation gives a **maximum boiling** azeotrope: nitric acid and water, at about 68% nitric acid by mass.