Topic 2

Natural selection at work

Darwin's idea rests on two facts. Members of a population vary, and more young are produced than can survive. Individuals whose variations suit the environment leave more offspring. Darwin called this fitness, and it means reproductive fitness, not strength.

A well-studied case comes from England. Moths were collected from the same area in the 1850s, before industrialisation, and again in 1920, after it.

Predict first

Before industrialisation, white-winged moths outnumbered dark-winged ones on the tree trunks. Factory smoke and soot then darkened the trunks. What happened by 1920?

This is industrial melanism. Before industrialisation the trunks were covered with pale lichens, which do not grow in polluted air. That is why lichens are used as indicators of air pollution. The same logic explains bacteria resistant to antibiotics and weeds resistant to herbicides: the resistant ones were already there and were selected.

Selection can push a trait, such as body size, in three ways. Pick each one below and compare the curve before and after.

Pick a kind of selection

original meansmallertrait valuelargerbefore selectionafter selection

Both extremes are removed. More individuals end up near the mean, so the curve becomes taller and narrower without moving.

The crosses mark the values that selection works against.

Remember the three

Stabilising: more individuals take the mean value. Directional: more individuals take a value away from the mean. Disruptive: more individuals take the values at both ends.