Topic 4

Why chlorobenzene resists substitution

In chlorobenzene the chlorine sits on a benzene ring. A lone pair on chlorine spreads into the ring by resonance, which gives the C–Cl bond partial double-bond character. The ring carbon is also sp² hybridised, which holds the bond shorter and tighter than the sp³ carbon of a haloalkane does.

Two more things work against substitution. The phenyl cation that SN1 would need is unstable, and an electron-rich nucleophile is repelled by the electron-rich ring. So chlorobenzene needs NaOH at 623 K and 300 atm to become phenol.

Predict first

Which compound would be converted to a phenol under the mildest conditions?

Add nitro groups and watch the temperature fall

Cltemperature needed (K)6230443136823223nitro groups
temperature
623 K
compound
chlorobenzene
conditions
NaOH, 623 K, 300 atm, then H⁺
product
phenol

Each nitro group at an ortho or para position makes the reaction easier: 623 K for plain chlorobenzene, 443 K with one nitro group para to Cl, 368 K with two (2,4) and only warm water at 322 K with three (2,4,6). A nitro group at the meta position has no such effect.

Electrophilic substitution is different

Haloarenes still undergo electrophilic substitution, such as nitration and halogenation, only more slowly than benzene. The halogen pulls electrons and slows the ring down, but its lone pairs send the new group to the ortho and para positions.